When is a PIP the right tool (or not)

This is a free article you might find interesting. It’s also a sample of our knowledge and how we can help you get a bit better at your job, and/or how we can help you fix a problem. If you’re interested in our consultation services, contact us.

This should go without saying but disclaimer: The information provided below is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, medical, or other professional advice. This article in particular, because any potential decision to proceed ahead despite assertions of rights in highly risky. You should consult with a qualified professional for specific advice tailored to your circumstances.

If you’re interested learning more about this topic, we have a range of courses that are very relevant (penalties and warnings, basics of performance management, advanced performance management for example), or you can find all of our courses here.

Often it’s pretty clear that the situation is a performance issue, but sometimes it’s not. Sometimes we are ‘umming and aahhing’ between misconduct or performance- a good example is lateness (how late is misconduct?, or how often AND how much is performance?). Here are some signs to look for. 

What is performance?

A performance problem is that it’s not within the person’s current capacity to do.  If someone is too short to reach something, they can’t.  This is different from won’t, which is where someone is able to do something, but chooses not to.  Can’t is the opposite of can, and can is question of capacity.   We all have limitations of what we can and can’t do- I can’t fly a space shuttle and neither can you. 

A people problem fails into this category where they cannot perform the tasks,but they should be able to do so in time.

What is performance management

Typically we are talking about poor performing employees who are not meeting the requirements of the role.  They need to give us X, and they are giving us less than X.  Performance management is interventions to solve the problem, to:

-        Give them clarity about what they need to do to meet the goal posts,

-        give them the upskilling they need,

To:

-        either to give them a fair chance to lift their game to regularly deliver the deliverables of the role,

-        or leave (the business or the role).

Signs that performance management is the right tool.

It is important to note that you should (or not, every situation is different) see the following characteristics:

  • What they can’t do is new to them, because they are a new to the role.  This could be a new hire, or a new promotion, but if they are struggling with something, you’d expect to see that it isn’t something that have routinely succeeded in before.

  • What they can’t do is new to them, because the job has evolved.  The outside world changes (see threats below) and this means that what and how a job is done will move with time.  A good example is technology, and older workers struggling with the new tools of the job, but it could be different customers, new markets and so on.  What has worked in the past to get the job done isn’t guaranteed to get the job done tomorrow. 

In short, look for history. If there is no history of this person doing this, then performance might be the right approach.

 Signs that performance management is not the right tool.

Sometimes performance managing someone is solving a problem with a hammer- if it’s not a nail (e.g. a screw), the tool won’t work and you’ll do a lot of damage. 

  • It’s not new.  The most common confusion between can’t (performance) and can’t (incapacity) is that the person isn’t performing something that they could have done before.   If someone can longer do something they used to be able to do, this is perhaps a sign that their body (and this includes their mind) has a problem.  It’s entirely possible that the problem is a physical constraint, not a loss of willingness to do the job.  This might not be the case, but its definitely worth a check. 

  • They aren’t doing things.  Theres a fine line between doing something less than well, or forgetting to take a step in a process (forgetting to turn on the shop alarm when doing the close is a one example).  But in some circumstances, an employee could simply be choosing to not do something.

Again, think of the history. If they have a history of doing what’s need in the past (and the situation is mostly the same) then not doing is more of a choice.

Confusing signs (it could be either, so some digging is required)

  • They are resisting.  This is a common aspect of these situation, that is often on the cusp of performance or misconduct. Do they really just not want to do what is required?  There is a whole ‘old dog new tricks’ subtext to this, but the underlying constaint we have is this:  we don’t know what they are thinking, so we can only address what we can see.  So we can only require them to do what needs to be done, not persuade them to like it.

  • They keep reverting back.  This has a similar on-the-cusp feel as above- if the employee reverts back to old habits after a period of doing the right thing.   For example coming into work on time, after this being discussed with them, but then going to back to tardy habits after a few months.   This can seen as misconduct, that they have chosen to do something they could do, but (most of the time), it’s a question of old habits re-emerging.

These are essentially questions of attitude to change. Is the person actively engaging with changing and fixing the gaps? or resisting, or dragging their feet? It’s a little simplistic to assume that they are poorly performing because of their mindset, when their mindset could be because of their performance.

Other similar articles:

Podcast episodes:

If you have a few seconds, we appreciate any feedback:

Next
Next

The case for negative values